The 2026 Galbani Professionale Pizza Cup Wraps in Orlando
The ovens were hot, the dough was flying and two pizza pros earned trips to Italy as the 2026 Galbani Professionale Pizza Cup wrapped up October 27 in Orlando, Florida. Hosted by the U.S. Pizza Team (USPT) alongside the Florida Restaurant Show and Pizza Tomorrow Summit, the three-day competition featured four culinary categories and four athletic challenges. Competitors baked their creations in PizzaMaster electric deck ovens, marking the debut of the team’s newest Gold Sponsor and official competition oven partner for 2027.
Two Grand Prize Winners Head to Italy
Mike Pitera of Pizza a Modo Mio captured the Pizza in the Pan championship with 365.99 points,
earning a trip to compete at the 2027 Campionato Mondiale della Pizza in Italy. Tim Holmes of Bella Napoli finished second with 358.49, followed by Chris Battiste of MiaAva East Coast Pizza with 358.23.
Entering at the last minute, Pitera stuck with a familiar recipe rather than reinventing the wheel. “I kept it simple and did my favorite ingredients, my favorite recipe, and it ended up working out,” he said.
The victory came after months of long workdays and the stress of opening his fourth location. “It made me really feel rewarded on all of my hard work,” Pitera said. “So it was very gratifying, and it was something I needed.”
The second Italy trip went to Michael Testa of Jersey Pizza Boys, who scored a perfect 300 points
with his revealing routine to win Freestyle Acrobatics. Patt Miller finished second with 279.46, while Doughtoli (Jacob Bartoli) of Papa John’s placed third with 274.30. Already known to a sizable online audience, Doughtoli’s participation brought an air of name recognizability to the new generation of fans and aspiring pizza spinners to the sport.
Miller, a former USPT member and longtime competitor with more than two decades of experience, has earned numerous culinary and acrobatic championships, including both Freestyle Acrobatics and Fastest Pie Maker at the 2025 Galbani Cup. Known for his crowd-pleasing performances, he brought the heat once again, literally, setting his spinning dough ablaze during his routine and adding another fiery moment to an already impressive competitive career, while the Champion slowly removed articles of clothing until only the societal bare minimum was left.
Testa said staying focused was essential, especially with his father watching. “While I’m performing, going through my head is my dad’s in the corner,” he said. “Just mentally, he’s there coaching me. And I know if I drop the dough once, twice, I’m gonna hear about it in the car.” he said with a chuckle.
For Testa, the competition is about more than trophies. “Just the passion for the game, just the inspiration you can give to others, the smiles that you put on people’s faces,” he said. “Everybody’s amazing here. So why wouldn’t you want to come?”
Antonio Aguila Tops On the Menu
The On the Menu category drew the competition’s largest field, challenging operators to showcase established restaurant offerings rather than one-off creations. Antonio Aguila of Uncle Rico’s Pizza, son of USPT member Enrico Aguila, claimed first place with 640.48 points. Tim Holmes finished second with 635.43, followed by Chris Battiste with 632.47.
Unfortunately, Aguila couldn’t stay to collect his hardware. He had to rush back to open the shop, leaving his parents to accept the awards on his behalf. The emotional moment left hardly a dry eye in the house.
Backyard Pizza Oven Brings the Heat
Sponsored by new USPT Bronze Sponsor Festa Pizza Co., the Backyard Pizza Oven competition
welcomed professional and amateur pizza makers to demonstrate their skills using Festa’s portable, high-heat ovens. Robert Butler of Lena’s Pizza claimed first place and a brand-new Festa pizza oven with 437.41 points, narrowly edging Chris Battiste at 435.83. Kelly Potter of Prohibition Pizza finished third with 405.02.
For Butler, the victory was worth the wait. After withdrawing at the last minute in 2025, he carried his registration over to 2026 and finally made his competition debut.
“It feels good. I wasn’t expecting it. Just surprised, honestly,” he said. His advice to other first-timers was simple: “Just do it, just for the experience. Just get out there and do it. You know, you never know.”
Speed, Skill and Flying Dough
The athletic competitions brought familiar faces and impressive
performances to the show floor. Patt Miller of Pizza Patt’s won Fastest Pizza Maker in 54.65 seconds, ahead of David Whisker at 1:09.78 and Chris Battiste at 1:15.12.
Whisker, meanwhile, has earned the nickname “The Blue Blur” for good reason. A multiple-time Galbani Cup champion in Fastest Pie Maker and Fastest Box Folder, he claimed another official box-folding victory in 25.66 seconds. Javier Gonzalez of Uncle Rico’s Pizza finished second at 31.78, followed by John McCaffrey at 34.59. Whisker returned for a no-stakes second round and improved to 21.05 seconds, proving he
still had another gear.
In Largest Dough Stretch, McCaffrey of Yellow Bridge Brewing took first with an average measurement of 27.19. Whisker finished second at 25.23, while William Howard of Peace of Pie on Hartwell placed third at 24.73 in his first competition.
A 27-year pizza veteran, McCaffrey credited patience and control. “Stay calm, be slow and methodical. Stay away from the middle of the dough, and just stay chill.”
Pizza for Two Closes the Competition
The final culinary challenge brought eight teams together for Pizza for Two (Pizza a Due), celebrating collaboration between pizza makers and their partners.
Enrico “Rico” Aguila and Johnny Budd of Uncle Rico’s Pizza captured first place with 382.25 points.
Julie Pitera and LJ Kardestuncer of Pizza a Modo Mio finished second with 366.26, followed by Alicia and Evan Singleton of Slice on Broadway at 360.60.
For Aguila, the victory continued a remarkable run. He won Best Cheese Pizza in 2024 and Pizza for Two alongside his son Antonio in 2025. This year, he teamed up with Budd, a first-time competitor, to claim another championship.
“I brought in Johnny Budd, it’s his first time competing, and he did an amazing job,” Aguila said. “I couldn’t have done this without a great pizzaiolo next to me.” Despite his own nerves, Aguila was impressed by his partner’s composure. “I’m looking at Johnny. I’m like, dude, this is his first competition. Why is he so calm?” he said. “We make a great team.”
Budd encouraged others to take the leap. “Don’t be afraid. It’s never too late. You could be in business your whole life, but you have to take that chance to be out there and put your name out there.”
More Than a Competition
Beyond trophies and trips to Italy, the Galbani Professionale Pizza Cup brings pizza professionals together to compete, learn and celebrate their craft. For Jim Binner, senior director of culinary for Lactalis USA’s Food Service Division, supporting the event means giving back.
“I have a passion for the industry and the people that are in it,” Binner said. “I wanted to make sure our organization is here to support and show some love back to the people that do the grind every day in their restaurants and their pizza shops.”
The USPT thanks Platinum and presenting sponsor Galbani Professionale, official competition oven sponsor PizzaMaster, and Festa Pizza Co. for supplying portable ovens and a prize. Additional thanks go to event sponsors Bee Dolce Hot Honey, Ooni Mixers, Plant Ahead USA, SunMix USA, MFG Tray, Grain Craft, GI Metal USA and Pizza University, event partners Pizza Tomorrow Summit and Florida Restaurant Show, and the judges, volunteers and competitors who made it all possible.
With two champions headed to Italy, the 2026 Galbani Professionale Pizza Cup once again celebrated great pizza, fierce competition and the people who keep the industry moving forward.